Best Sticky Toffee Pudding and Custard in Whitby

2 restaurant menus in United Kingdom, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Sticky Toffee Pudding and Custard
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Shepherds Hall Tea Rooms Lealholm
Shepherds Hall Tea Rooms Lealholm
95/100 (7660 ratings)
Browse the menu
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
British
Cafe
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Lunch
Brunch
Treacle Sponge with Custard
Salad
Sticky Toffee Pudding and Custard
Cheese and Onion Toasted Sandwich
Hot Chocolate with Marshmallows
Fruit Scone with Strawberry Jam
Sticky Toffee Pudding with Chocolate Ice Cream
Coronation Cake
Toasts
Cakes
Steak pie
Cappuccino
Sandwiches
english breakfast
Afternoon tea
Chicken pie
Chocolate Fudge Cake
"We’ve been going to shepherds hall since the new owners opened,always made to feel welcome and we’ve seen the place blossom into the great place..."
David Barton
"Here on Friday 26th July. Beautiful weather and surroundings. Great food and pot of tea. Melting in the heat! A must refuelling stop if you are in..."
Malcolm Bowstead
"Lovely tea room and gift shop, friendly staff with lots of choice of food and delicious cakes at a reasonable price. Also serves Sunday..."
Julie Ferguson
"Visited yesterday sat in the outside area at the back overlooking the river was just beautiful fruit scones were the nicest I have ever had was just..."
Julie Arnold
"Loved it ....loved it....loved it! A great all round experience from the friendly fantastic service, the decor and relaxing decor through to an..."
Debbie Dunkerton
"Lovely food, lovely people, and dog friendly. Visited 3 times during our stay in the village and will definately be returning next year..."
Hannah O'leary
"Fabulous place owned and run by two wonderful people. Food is of a high standard and all are welcome. Especially..."
Kelly Clayton
"Gorgeous little place to stop, fill up and dry off..."
Stephanie Nicholls-Pickering
"Fantastic pie n mash night tonight. Lovely desserts too! Will definitely visit again. Thank..."
Julie Richards
"visited Shepherds Hall on Tuesday 4/06/2013----Lovely Tea Room, beautiful setting, quaint tea-cups and food great, sandwiches and soup . Yorkshires..."
Diane Scarlett
"A warm welcome and excellent, reasonably priced food. Great garden with..."
Jennie Todd
"Wondering where we could get refreshment on a rainy Saturday afternoon and the tea room came to mind. Owned by the lovely Ellie, Sarah and Paul,..."
Kathryn Atkinson
"Great Coffee and Flapjack. Really friendly people. Deffinatly be stopping there again when out..."
Derek Ricketts
"Good cuppa and cake after a hike over the Moors. They also do good for the more hungry. Indoor seating available, but we sat outside over looking the..."
Jim Ladd
"2021 5 star: Good service, good food. Would recommended. 2022 Update 4 star : The service is a little slower but seemed to be busy. The menu is..."
Joseph Conway
"Delicious food prepared with care and passion. Plenty of parking, a restful atmosphere and tea in a proper tea pot. (Photo: Salmon and asparagus..."
Paul Longden
"We first found this lovely cafe last year shortly after the new owners moved in and enjoyed it so much we returned this year to see how they are..."
Peter Russell
"We were staying locally and had heard good reports of Shepherds Hall so we thought we'd pop in and give it a try. So pleased we did. Everything was..."
Dave Edwards
"Googled somewhere different to go and this popped up. What a gem! Open sandwiches were awesome and fruit scones Jan and cream yum yum. 3 cups of tea..."
Derek Beadman-Newitt
"Lovely tea room with very friendly service. Tea room itself is up some steps, but has a nice tea garden to sit outside in the summer. Also has its..."
Garry Stonehouse
"Stopped off in the pretty village of Lealholm, whilst driving over the moors. It was lunch time so visited these tea rooms. So glad we did, proper..."
Marilyn Stanley
Magpie Cafe
Magpie Cafe
90/100 (24022 ratings)
Browse the menu
Restaurants
European
British
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
British
European
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Brunch
After-hours
Dinner
Lunch
Oysters with Lemon and Tobasco
Hake
Salad
Magpie Medley
Paella
Crab
Crab Bisque Warm Roll and Butter
Fish & chips
Cakes
Scallops
Puddings
Oyster
Cake
Fish
Mussels
Scampi
fish n chips
Prawn cocktail
Sea Bass
Salmon
Fried
Absolutely
Afternoon tea
Monkfish
Cup of Tea
Gluten Free Fish and Chips
Garlic mushrooms
Fresh Fish
Sticky Toffee Pudding and Custard
Fish pie
Fish & Chips
Fish Pie
Mussels and Chips
Lobster thermidor
Haddock
Plaice
Crab Starter
Cod
Mushy Peas
Fish and Chips
Halibut
Scallops
Prawns
Regular Size Cod and Chips Plus Mushy Peas
Hot Seafood Pot
Lobster
Sit down
British
European
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Reservations
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Dinner
After-hours
Lunch
Brunch
Mid-range
"This is in my mind without doubt the finest fish and chip restaurant in the country. We have tried many , but this is the..."
John Purves
"Lovely food. Try to leave room for pudding. Even the small portions fill the plate. Fish available with or without..."
Garry Ely
"Childhood memories came flooding back. Introduced the kids to the joy that is the Magpie. They loved it! Food as fantastic as ever and only ten..."
Adam Lindsay
"Just returned home from my fourth visit to the area and the Magpie was a must, just as it has been on previous visits. Great food, generous..."
Randy Broadwater
"Excellent service from the staff. Food was out of this world ....and the surprise cake and getting the place to sing happy birthday was..."
Layne Cap Moore
"Absolutely loved the place.Stunning food and the staff were really..."
Angie Beddow
"Best place in Whitby to have fish and chips go there every time lovely staff..."
Eileen Joan Whitehead
"My favourite food is chips. Today I tasted the best chips and scraps in my whole life. Will be coming back to Whitby 5 hr journey..."
Jen Elsden
"Best fish, chips and mushy peas in the world , and the staff are fab, they are so busy, happy smiley people, can't wait ro go back again,..."
Gillian Noon
"Delicious! Have been searching for great fish and chips since I arrived from Australia and finally found them! I had hoped to have the skate, but was..."
Aoife
"Most people in Yorkshire, especially those who have visited Whitby will tell you that the best place to get fish and chips in Whitby, or even on the..."
Breadsticklers
"Went there with a few others. Heard this place was quite a well known spot but didn't quite know how to be too excited about fish and chips. I stand..."
Kishore Mitra
"Our first excursion was in the seaside, port town of Whitby. It was such a lovely town, I was impressed by the fact there was a queue nearly outside..."
Jeanne-Marie B
"... it’s definitely a slice of Yorkshire that you shouldn’t..."
London Piggy
"It’s hard not to fall in love with the food being served at The Magpie Cafe, a North Yorkshire fish and chip institution. And, judging by the..."
Gourmet Gorro
"This is good old simple fish and chips. The fish from here is definitely fresh and came with a batter that was non-greasy, crispy and light in..."
Chopstix2steaknives
"I have been looking forward to eating here for a while and everything was as I had expected. The fish is cooked in beef dripping and this added..."
Roland Samuels
"Wanted to say thank you for such a beautiful lunch meal on Monday. Myself and my grandparents had a lovely lunch. The menu is plentiful with so many..."
Ellie Rogan
"No questions about this place winning; definitely worthy the awards they keep receiving… Probably one of the Best cod, chips, mushy peas in North..."
Yami
"Probably the best fish restaurant in North Yorkshire. Fish and chips were freshly served and the batter was amazing. Great service with friendly..."
Steve Ellis
"Had a lovely to course set meal lots of choice and food was delicious. Staff could not have been more helpful. Any food being served at other tables..."
William Tobin
"We had been recommended to eat here by a friend who had eaten here around 15 years ago, so to be honest, we didn't think it would still be as good ...."
Shell Milt
"Our family of four visited here after a recommendation and wasn’t disappointed. The staff were friendly and welcoming but not in your space. We..."
Karen Kenyon
"Couldn't believe there was no queue when we arrived. If we had queued, it would have been well worth the wait. It was delicious!..."
Morag Tucker
"We did the 2 courses for £21 The mussels, calamari and fish and chips were gorgeous 😍 I drank the creamy sauce the mussels were..."
Nicole Todd
"One of the best fish&chips I have ever had! The fish was not salty and everyone can use as much salt or vinegar as they desire. If I go here next..."
Klaudi
"Scrumptious! Second time visiting here and it always hits the spot. It is very popular which is understandable as it’s super flavourful! My only..."
Lu Young
"Visited last Easter Sunday evening, we hadn't booked but a lovely warm welcome and seated straight away. We ordered and drinks arrived quickly myself..."
Mrs Cjb
"Stunning food! The Magpie was recomended by a friend of mine - and we are so glad we went (and that we booked as it was super busy!!). Service was..."
AJ Green
"Passed the Magpie many times always a queue. Walked straight in today, still busy. Very enjoyable regular cod and chips and a pint of Whitby Heritage..."
Mick Byett
"We went to The Magpie Cafe on a recommendation and pre booked online in advance. We arrived early due to bad weather and the staff were able to seat..."
Becky Albrecht
"Went to this place for lunch. Had the scallops and black pudding and also the crab bisque for starters which were delicious, and I would highly..."
Alexandria Lau
"A very delicious meal (Cod & chips). Fish was cooked lovely and batter was nice and crisp. Home made onion rings were tasty and all washed down with..."
Darren Colson
"A real gem if you like seafood or even if you're with someone who loves seafood. The focus here is the food, the setting isn't fancy or gimmicky and..."
Simon Mohr
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use