Best Carbonara in Whitby

2 restaurant menus in United Kingdom, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Cosa Nostra
Cosa Nostra
90/100 (5394 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
After-hours
Dinner
Lunch
Calzone Vegetariano
Risotto
Puddings
Side Salad
Lamb
Mussels
Sea Bass
Bistecca
Bruschette
Salmon
Calzone Pizza
Pesto
Pizza Quattro Stagioni
Fish
Fish & Chips
Prawn Linguine
Ragu
Haddock
Linguine Frutti Di Mare
Spaghetti carbonara
Mussels in White Wine and Garlic Sauce
Chips
Green salad
Prawns
Garlic Bread Marinara
Pepperoni Pizza
Carnivoro Pizza
Lasagne
Tiramisu
Crème Brûlée
Fish & chips
Lasagne
Garlic Prawns
Antipasto Misto
Carbonara
Pasta
Penne
Bruschetta Caprese
Chicken Wings
Salad
Linguine
Mushroom Risotto
Garlic Prawns
Duck
Calzone
Sit down
Italian
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
After-hours
Dinner
Mid-range
"Love this Italian been a few times when staying in Whitby. This time on a Thursday in November and it was still busy so recommend booking. Young..."
David Wilson
"Cosa Nostra from start to finish was first class. All the staff couldn't help enough. Great food, great service and excellent..."
Dan Maloney
"Absolutely thrilled with the experience. Loveliest staff we’ve ever encountered and the food was incredible. Don’t usually leave reviews but was..."
CHARLIE THORPE
"Wow!!! A truly amazing find. The food is out of this world. A varied menu with plenty of choice but not a huge menu which means that the kitchen can..."
Lee Simpson
"Always a sure sign of a good restaurant how busy it is, looked to be pretty much full. Casa nostra has a nice feel and ambience. The menu is somewhat..."
T Vickers
"Fantastic service once again. I’ve lost count of how many times we have visited and we have never been disappointed. Even on a busy service, the..."
Kate Wilson
"What a fabulous find in Whitby. Our last day of a lovely holiday and we were looking for something different from the usual fish and chips. I would..."
david Senior
"Food here is great and a real breath of fresh air in its location. It has air conditioning as well, so great on those hit evenings. Gets busy, so..."
martin summers
"Lovely relaxed atmosphere. Staff were excellent. Food was absolutely spot. Would highly..."
David Fleming
"Great food and service. The staff were incredible and a credit to the..."
Mark Fox
Moutreys
Moutreys
74/100 (4177 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Pizza
European
Italian
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
European
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
After-hours
Dinner
Lunch
Lasagne
Crab
Garlic Prawns Starter
Carbonara
Mussels
Pollo Arrabiata
Mussels in a Cream and Wine Sauce
Halloumi
Salmon
Spicy Chicken Fusilli
Chocolate Brownie
Garlic Prawns
Pepperoni
Cakes
Fish & Chips
Brownie
Fish & chips
Calzone
Pesto
Puddings
Fish
Antipasti
Cod
Cake
Meat Feast Pizza
Spaghetti carbonara
Prawns
Chorizo
Burger
Bread and Oil
Calzone
Sea Bass
Spinach and Ricotta Cannelloni
Spaghetti Bolognese
Chocolate Brownie
And Hand Cut Chips
Pepperoni Pizza
Bass
Side Salad
Pizza Oven
Sirloin
Lasagne
Red wine
Meatballs
Pasta
Antipasto
Cider
Seafood Pasta
Bolognese
Salad
Macaroni and Cheese
Sit down
Pizza
European
Italian
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
After-hours
Dinner
Mid-range
"Wow! Quirky, eclectic, fantastic atmosphere, friendly staff, generous portions, beautifully cooked and tasty food, honest, unpretentious and very..."
Simon Knight
"Huge pizzas from a huge wood fired oven. Great atmosphere and service. Just been back and it's still just as good. Enormous calzone this time, which..."
Naich Roolz
"5 of us came here for a ladies meal out. Between us we had 3 different meals with a couple of us ordering the same thing. All meals were simply..."
Hayley Ashcroft
"We booked a table on the mezzanine and it was everything you'd expect. Private, romantic and complete. Fantastic service from the staff and awesome..."
Daniel Dunn
"Lovely atmospheric Italian Great menu,lots of choices. I went for the Vegetable Calzone and it was amazing- nice touch also to have green olives..."
Keith Barker
"Lively atmosphere, good choice of food & drinks albeit a bit pricey, friendly staff, good service, nice location, quirky restaurant, gave 4* not 5*..."
Soosan Webbo
"Really great food and service! My partner has a nut allergy. The staff were really helpful and the kitchen was able to cater for him easily. We'll..."
Caroline Hill
"Very nice food, great location, good service. Squeezed us in without a reservation which was appreciated! Food was quick and excellent. Service was..."
Chris
"Really good food at a very reasonable price, be aware they don't mess around with portion sizes. Enough to feed two on a single plate. We had..."
Stefan Kirby
"The food was lovely and you got plenty of it. The portions are huge. I'm not complaining as I love my food 😋. Definitely worth a visit and I would..."
Andrea Edwardson
"Had a lovely meal, meal sizes are quite large so definitely good value for money. Not expensive at all. Only thing I would say is its abit crammed,..."
Karl Radunovic
"Booked in for our 2nd wedding anniversary. The sign on the door said please bare with us short of staff, well not a problem. I had the chorizo..."
David Garrison
"Lovely restaurant great staff. The food is absolutely fantastic definitely worth trying if you have..."
Nick “Whitby reviewer” Doddy
"Lovely restaurant, i have never had garlic bread as delicious as it was here , and even the bread that came with the olives was superb, our mains..."
greta dobson