Best Carbonara in Sheffield

5 restaurant menus in United Kingdom, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Olive Restaurant
Olive Restaurant
98/100 (2401 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegan Options
Mediterranean
Italian
Mediterranean
Moroccan
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Moroccan
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Fish
Surf and Turf
Ragu
Scallops
Crème Brulée
Seafood
Champagne Chicken
Surf And Turf
Sea Bass
King Prawn and Mushroom Linguini
Tiramisu
Beef
Slow Cooked Lamb
Baked Brie with Chutney
Slow Cooked Moroccan Lamb
Bass
Onion Soup
Penne
Meatballs
Fried
Meat Pizza
Pasta
Crab
Linguine
Creme Brulee
Prawn Starter
Mixed Grill Platter
Calamari
Brownie
Arancini
Truffle
Grilled Seabass
Moroccan Meat Balls
Mussels
Calzone
Focaccia
Wild Mushrooms
Tagine
Meatball Starter
Calamares
Puddings
Tagliatelle
Seafood Linguine
Mango Panna Cotta
Panna cotta
Halloumi
Penne Pasta
Beef Pasta
Brie
Lamb
Seabass King Prawns
Pâté
Sea Bass
Bruschette
Arancini
Pesto
Carbonara
Prawns
Sit down
Moroccan
Italian
Mediterranean
Table Service
Reservations
Serves Alcohol
Seating
Wine and Beer
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Street Parking
Dinner
Mid-range
"Have been to Olive a few times and it is always delicious, great service and a lovely ambience. Definitely advise booking as it is always busy! And..."
Philippa Norgrove
"We had an incredible birthday celebration here! Firstly, the staff were friendly, attentive and knew the menu inside and out! Secondly, the food..."
Steve mcgarry
"Fantastic restaurant. Best steak I’ve had anywhere. Menu is varied with some stunning dishes. Service was also great in such a lively..."
Adam Murray
"We had a beautiful meal here last night! My son's 30th birthday and nothing was too much trouble. We dropped banners and balloons off earlier and..."
Sarah Pelter
"Not our first time. Food here is fantastic 😋 I would recommend highly!!!! I had the special (T-bone steak) was seasoned beautifully and cooked..."
Rupert Allen
"Saturday night during the England quarter finals. Very busy yet the service was excellent, very friendly and efficient staff. All the food was..."
Nick Shepherd
"Have had Olive on my list of places to eat in Sheffield for a while, and finally got round to visiting. Firstly the decor is lovely and has such a..."
Laura Wright
"Great atmosphere, the waitresses were really nice they took our coats when we walked in. The food was great I ordered the king prawns and my partner..."
stanley griffinz
"This is one of the very best restaurants in Sheffield. Incredible flavours, calm atmosphere, I can't fault anything and looking forward to going..."
Julian Ursell
"Food had good flavours and the right portion. 1st time visiting, would visit again. Small restaurant with great..."
Shazza
Piacere Gusti E Sapori
Piacere Gusti E Sapori
97/100 (49 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Peppers
Croquette
Torta Caprese
Antipasto Italiano
Veggi Burger
Panzerotto
Carrot Cake
Burrata
Fish and Chips
Carbonara
Risotto
Spit Roast Chicken Marinated
polpette
Oysters Rockefeller
Italian
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
"Such a lovely little restaurant on Abbeydale Road. Fantastic range of traditional homemade Italian dishes in a warm and cosy dining area. Never..."
Paul Bestall
"Sat outside with our puppy and thoroughly enjoyed our experience! From the staff to the food everything was lovely. We will be back! Thank you..."
sarah barley
"Great panini, absolutely massive with great spicy sausage and assorted veg..."
Martin Kershaw
"Delicious food, great service and nice venue. Fantastic panini. I ordered one for lunch and took the rest home for my dinner! Lovely place and will..."
claudia calvino
"Nice food, amazing service will go again..."
Billy Lones
"Friendly efficient greeting when we went for lunch. The menu was just the right size, plenty of choice but not ridiculously long. The food (chicken..."
Patricia Edney
"Fabulous chicken and amazing arancini. We decided to call in for Sunday lunch and ordered the half chicken with roast potatoes with a side if..."
Janice Glover
"Just been for a meal with my wife for the first time. Have to say from the moment we got there they made us feel welcome. They brought us a bottle of..."
stephen ireson
"First takeaway from La Baracca and won't be the last. The food was delicious and very good value for money. The chicken was roasted perfectly and we..."
Ally Cooke
"What a great find, beautiful little restaurant on AbbeyDale Road, lovely authentic food. Warm, friendly staff. I will be..."
Georgina Bohan
"Had a group meal here and it was fantastic, everything was delicious. Even though it has a focus on chicken the vegetarians were also well catered..."
Peter Caven
"We had a takeaway meal this evening, our first experience of La Baracca, and we were very impressed. Lovely starters (arancini verdi and uova..."
Paul Thomas
"Had some lovely chicken last night at La Baracca. Fantastic service and really nice food. Really great value and good quality simple food. Will..."
Sarah Jarvis
"Great authentic food and great service. Will definitely be going back sometime soon..."
Gemma Walker
"Cute little restaurant. Just a handful of tables. Lovely service and good menu that had something for everyone in our party. Food was good, and..."
Terri Pugh
"Simply delicious food and wonderful, friendly service. Will definitely tell friends and family. Best food I have had in Sheffield for a long time...."
Stephen Givnan
"Amazing homecooked food, so friendly and perfect cosy at atmosphere. So pleased we found this place! And does..."
Tessa Hamer
Ferdinandos Eatalian
Ferdinandos Eatalian
89/100 (1210 ratings)
Restaurants
Mediterranean
European
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
European
Pizza
Mediterranean
Italian
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Dinner
Drinks
Beer
Lasagne Bolognese
Tiramisu
Seabass
Seafood linguine
Chicken Pate
Bass
Gressingham Duck
Steak with Vegetables
Meatballs
Tagiatelli Fruitti De Mare
Lasagne
Pancakes
Stuffed Tomatoes with Rice
Carbonara
Cake
Pasta
Creamy Garlic Mushroom Pasta
Minestrone
Sea Bass
Risotto
Creamy Mushroom and Bruschetta
Cakes
Tiramisú
Lamb
Carbonara
Bruschette
Antipasto
Pesto
Fish
Minestrone
Antipasto
Prawns
Linguine
Calzone
Venison
Pappardelle
Affogato
Seafood Risotto
Sit down
Pizza
European
Mediterranean
Italian
Full Bar
Digital Payments
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Family style
BYOB
Non-smoking restaurants
Seating
Takeout
Table Service
Reservations
Private Dining
Wheelchair Accessible
Street Parking
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Drinks
Dinner
Mid-range
"First time here tonight having travelled up from Winchester for a family visit. Amazing place, delicious food and friendly and welcoming staff. I've..."
Sarah Lowe
"Once again everything about the night was excellent. From our arrival to going home we were made really welcome. The front of house staff Ferdi/Ruben..."
Keith Hall
"Went last night for a family celebration. There were 13 of us and not one of us had a bad meal. Quite the contrary,....the food was amazing. My..."
Jo Kate McKenzie
"Food is always great, and atmosphere lively. Shame Ferdinando wasn’t there, he is charm personified! Unlike the new waiter who is a tad on the..."
Lindsey Hallam
"Had a great meal, service as usual superb. Staff miss nothing and the food was fantastic. This place never fails to disappoint. The atmosphere is so..."
Dave Stringfellow
"Gorgus meal just visited husbands birthday we’ve visited lots of Italians and never realised the best was on our doorstep great service tasty food..."
Dawn Owen Howard
"Everything from stepping in to stepping out was first class the best Italian meal I’ve had this side of the Mediterranean definitely going back..."
Lloyd Sharman
"Always a great welcome awaits with great food and service with a little banter with the staff always makes for a great evening or lunch..."
Bruce Panks
"Great food & atmosphere & the staff are very accommodating. The last two times I visited they made me a vegetarian sauce to accompany pasta & were..."
Ange Fanthorpe
"Franck and I went yesterday(Sunday) to celebrate our good fortune week...I had lasagne, he had the oxtail, both beautifully cooked and..."
Sharron Reed-skill
"Thank you for making my daughters birthday special and for calling us about the accidental large tip. Lovely evening and as usual we really enjoyed..."
Boo Katherine
"Fantastic place ,great food ,great staff and atmosphere ,will definitely visit again..."
Sharon Garrard Towers
"New chef, new food on the menu same great..."
Ian Russell
"I'm from Italian descent and the food is authentic, great atmosphere , the staff are so nice and make you feel so welcome . You must visit this..."
Anna Palermo
"Ottimo ristorante, dai sapori italiani. Gestito da un grandissimo chef. Un vero italiano nato in..."
Francesco Artista Terelle
"Excellent as always. BYO wine - Mitchells next door has great selection. One of the best in Sheffield and def the best tomato garlic bread in..."
Yvonne Wilkinson
"Beautiful afternoon the restaurant provided another fantastic meal experience for us. We were lucky to secure a table in the afternoon, especially..."
ann-marie myers
"Visited today, food was beautiful- compliments to the chefs! I had the spinach ravioli. Service by Nihat, Gennaro and Marcus was great too. Felt so..."
Jasmine Booth
"Visit at Fernando's Eatalian restaurant with my Wife for our 25th wedding anniversary.. The food is absolutely delicious. We did not waste our food...."
James. F
"Just popped in tonight off the cuff with no booking, the place was busy, the staff were very welcoming, the food and service turned out to be..."
Steve Hunter
"Had a lovely meal here tonight with friends. Waiter very friendly and attentive but not overly over our shoulders. Food well worth the..."
Allison Staley
"We visited for the valentines set menu last night and everything was perfect. The food was amazing and even with it being a set menu I was able to..."
Olivia Cropper
"We’ve been twice now and the food, staff & atmosphere is truly the best. First visit was just my husband and myself, 2nd visit was with some family..."
Juliet Keen
"Lovely restaurant, the staff are lovely. Food is amazing. Quick service. We have been ger twice and will definitely come back again. We have..."
Deborah Emmerson
"I would just like to say what a great afternoon me and my family had with the new owners at Ferdinando's today. I don’t normally do reviews but..."
Nick Fisher
"Ferdinando’s is a traditional Italian restaurant now under new management with really nice owners. Marco the fantastic head waiter is very..."
Ally Cowen
Bella Italia
Bella Italia
84/100 (4390 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Healthy
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Healthy
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
After-hours
Spaghetti Bolognese
Gluten Free Brownie
english breakfast
Traditional Lasagne
Ribs
Pepperoni Pizza
Calzone Carne
Prawns
Burger
prosecco
Tiramisú
Carbonara
Meatballs
Pasta
Meatballs
Risotto
Cheesecakes
Pasta
Calamari My Favourite
Lasagne
Salad
Pancakes with Lemon and Sugar
Carbonara
Duck
Calzone
Gelato
Salami
Risotto
Cake
Chicken Wings
Espresso Martini
Lamb
Strawberry Lemonade
Pesto
Pollo Cacciatore
Cheesecake
Tea
Gluten Free Chocolate Brownie
Sit down
Healthy
Pizza
Italian
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Seating
Accepts Mastercard
Table Service
Accepts Visa
Wheelchair Accessible
Reservations
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Mastercard
Parking Available
Visa
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Brunch
After-hours
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"We recently had the pleasure of dining at Bella Italia. The ambience set the tone for a delightful experience. The food was simply amazing, each dish..."
Arya Vayalil Chathoth
"George was just fantastic!! So funny. He was charming and professional. I had a horrible experience once in London Stratford and was nervous to come,..."
Jaspal Jhagra
"We went to Bella Itália after an ice skating session, our meal was good, and the service was fast and..."
Rachel Cabral
"Food was lovely portion was a little small especially for the price. Was greeted by Will who was so helpful & friendly. Answered any questions we..."
entela tia
"Our 3rd visit. Great food and service by George. Extra portion of ice cream for Jackie as a birthday treat was very nice. Will definitely be..."
Andy Wragg
"Lovely food and staff! Would definitely go..."
Lauren Ballard
"The food was amazing 👏. Great service 👌 and..."
Sarah Gerrett
"Food is ok. But very pricey. £20 for a BBQ Spare ribs..."
James. F
"Both the waitress and manager were friendly and knowledgable about the food. I loved my calamari starter but only liked my spag carbonara as it..."
Peter Cooper
"Really good options if you eat gluten-free. There were several options included in the set menu for each course. The food came out quickly and was..."
Lisa Bailey
"Ellena was lovely! Really friendly and helpful. The food was really nice too. Good atmosphere, especially for a Sunday night near closing. The set..."
Becki McNay
"Been coming here for over 15 years. Friendly staff efficient service great atmosphere and lovely food and drinks. Highly..."
Julie Cain
"Decided to take my parents here for Mothers' Day and my dad's birthday. They've never been before (we go quite often), but they really enjoyed it...."
Heather Lily
"Never had a bad meal here. Service is great so is the atmosphere. A bit pricey though for what you get so we don’t tend to go unless we have a..."
Steve Seyboth
"Food was lovely and good portion sizes and very tasty . Lady at front desk and who served us was terrific and amazing with my daughter who was..."
ryan tab
"Really nice branch with lots of different types of seating. Chose a table by the sunny window overlooking the outside seating area. I like a padded..."
S. Shutt
Lost & Found Sheffield
Lost & Found Sheffield
79/100 (2123 ratings)
Bars & Pubs
Restaurants
Bar
British
Bar
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
British
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Drinks
Carbonara
Carbonara
Cake
Arancini
Sea Bass
Cakes
Burger
Truffle
Pesto
Fish
Cheese Balls
Pork
Espresso Martini
Fish and chips
Scone
Pasta
Pork Belly
Blackberry
Salad
Cocktails
Wagyu Beef Burger Topped
Warm Breads
Duck
Wine
Warm Chocolate Cake
Beer
8oz Fillet Steak
Champagne
Pastries for Afternoon Tea
Duck breast
It's the Duck
Coconut Curry
Fish and Chips
British
Bar
Street Parking
Live Music
Reservations
Seating
Serves Alcohol
Table Service
Wine and Beer
Wheelchair Accessible
Gift Cards Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Family style
Dog Friendly
Outdoor Seating
Private Dining
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Mid-range
"We hosted a baby shower at lost and found yesterday in the conservatory. The venue is stunning it was the perfect day to have an outdoor celebration,..."
Jordanne Downes
"Having a nice day last summer here. The place is nice, plenty of seats available with different atmosphere. Their food were good but for me it's..."
Widi Desti
"Great food, lovely staff, we went at a quiet time, so not much ambiance, but still a great..."
Rachel Williamson
"16 of us for a retirement meal. Service was spot on, very attentive staff, polite a friendly. The food was of high standard. It was a very enjoyable..."
rowan russell
"A fantastic bottomless brunch experience for my birthday, thank you so much for making it special. Received a free birthday cocktail on arrival which..."
Lucy M
"the pizzas here were really damn good. We really enjoyed. Staff were really helpful and friendly, made us feel super welcome, I think they were..."
Archie Baker
"Booked the private room for my daughters baby shower, cannot express how perfect everything was, from pre booking to on the day I couldn’t have..."
Natalia Prime
"Had our work Christmas dinner here. I'm not really a foodie person but there was a group of 14 of us, all the food came out together, it tasted good..."
Jeremy Peck
"Evie and Taylor were very friendly and attentive. Evie took the time to talk me through the cocktail selection and Taylor discussed our meal choices...."
Michele Bower
"Had a great time at bottomless brunch on a Saturday afternoon. We had to wait around 20 minutes for our first drink, but then Tullia and served us..."
Courtney Essex