Reviews Piccolos Italian Restaurant

I feel very comfortable dining at Piccolos in Sheffield alone. I am made to feel very welcome, at ease and not rushed. Asides from having a mouthwatering menu, all dishes are flexible to include/disclose ingredients to meet your taste or tolerance issues if any. Front of house waitress Justine is welcoming, understanding and articulate when it comes to anything on the menu. I am lucky to live a 2 minute stroll from this restaurant and will be dining there regularly with both friends and corporate groups alike. Long story short, there are no negatives about this restaurant and I would challenge anyone who says otherwise

Had to share what a fantastic meal we have had this evening. The staff went above and beyond to fit us in as we had not pre booked, we were so grateful and genuinely lost count how many others were turned away as they were so busy. The food was beautiful, tasty, authentic and served well. The service from every single member of the team was also outstanding. Thank you for fitting us in, myself and my husband will be back.

My favourite italian restaurant in sheffield! I have visited Italy a few times and can say the food comes perfectly close! I highly recommend this restaurant especially as the service is so lovely and welcoming.

Had a fantastic time at the restaurant! Food quality was outstanding, every dish was delicious in its own style, service was no exception. Trust me, my comments are not just boasts. The place is definitely romantic. This now became one of my favorite restaurants in the UK. Thanks Piccolo's ! 🧡

7 of us went on a Tuesday early evening. Not one of us had anything negative to say about any part of our time here. The food was absolutely delicious, including the starters and desserts… mother in law said it was the best lasagne she’s ever had, kids had pasta (one spicy tomato and one carbonara) both loved it! One of us had a pizza and the rest of us had pollo picante with different sides - honestly the nicest Italian we’ve had in forever. The food in Limone, Lake Garda doesn’t come close to Sheffields Piccolos! The restaurant has a very homely and welcoming atmosphere, and our waitress Justine was so friendly and polite, nothing was too much trouble. Thank you to the chefs and Justine - we had a brilliant evening here and we’re very grateful xx

I’ve been here twice, and the service is great. My first experience was amazing, we ordered the bread for starters. Then for the main we got the Margherita pizza, one of the cream pastas and a Risotto. We also tried the tiramisu and panna cotta. They were all tasty, but the pasta and the panna cotta are definitely the highlights of the day - definitely worth getting. The second time I went was a bit of a let down. I ordered the garlic mushrooms as a starter, and it was just ok. The pasta was a massive disappointment. It was a seafood pasta and the only fresh tasting seafood in the pasta was the squid, and there was barely any in the dish. The pasta to seafood ratio was imbalanced. The mussels were the worst part - they tasted horrible, and the sauce was watery and bland. Thankfully though, the meal ended on a positive note. I reordered the panna cotta I had last time and it’s still as nice as I first had it. Overall, I think this place is decent. Quite pricey, and the menu items are a hit or miss. Also, just being picky on my end, but I wished the waiters pushed the bread a little less because they asked me 5 times. Still a place worth trying imo.