Excellent Sunday dinner, little bit more meat it would have been 100 per cent perfect, wouldn't mind paying extra ,staff very helpful, nice
Over all nice looking pub, friendly feeling as you walk in . Food was of high quality very tasty worth every penny spent and even had a pudding ..reasonably priced . Overall very happy with my first visit.. i shall return if only for the food and friendly staff
What a find! Not only very dog friendly but with wonderful staff and beautiful food. The steak and ale pie was to die for
Absolute gem of Pickering food exquisite and for the quality of it under priced, facilities spotless, landlady a true old fashioned style landlady makes everyone welcome and nothing is to much trouble for her, as someone in the trade my self I know it's hard to satisfy everybody but you excel in what you do, the restaurant was fairly busy and food came out swiftly and again I can't praise it enough ��
Very friendly and the food was delicious. Clean and quaint. Couldn't fault it in any way. Definitely recommend it.
Made very welcome, food was superb, best steak in a long while, lovely fresh veg, great steak pie, chunky chips, good choice of beers. Staff excellent. Definitely be back!
Would recommend The Bay Horse to all, lovely and friendly pub, meal was amazing very tasty. Definitely going back soon.
Thoroughly enjoyed my 'gluten free' arrangement (mix of a starter and side dish served as a main). Great service to accommodate my strange taste and allergy. Lovely food and great service - thank you 😀
Had a lovely meal last, staff was very friendly & helpful, also welcome dogs bonus. Will definitely be going again thanks. �
We run a B&B in Pickering at Eleven Westgate so we have to regularly research the local places to eat and drink (!). The Bay Horse offers another great option with the cosy local feel Cromwell Bar (real fire and historic photos of Pickering) and the multi level Lounge with snugs, good food and pool table. With great staff, Peter and Suszan have done a great job and we now have another place which we will sneak into for a cheeky one (and recommend for our guests).
Lovely pub. Didn’t sample the food but the carvery looked good. 4 real ales to try
Fantastic pub! Great staff and good beer! What more could you want !
Beautiful pub, warm open fire, wonderful staff, beautiful food, just love it there and the pints are to die for
Great pub and we won the Sunday night quiz everything collected went to the air ambulance charity and great staff and friendly locals
Great place. Mix of locals and visitors. Dog friendly. Food was great and selection impressive. Good selection of beers. Decent, comfortable and friendly town pub.
Good beer (Black Sheep), good food and a very friendly landlady from the NE. Interesting locals. Proper pub decor. What more could anyone want ?
Love this place. Chilled and friendly with great pub grub and a cracking little bear garden - all right smack in the middle of town
Scampi and chips were lovely as was the steak baguette. - will definitely return next time we are in the area
Nice place this. Right on Pickering main street. Easy to find. Park right outside of at the Co op car park. Friendly staff senisble prices. Food was very good. Well worth a visit. Would recommend and would go again. Does get busy on sat night though.
Just had a Sunday lunch. I had gammon and the wife had beef both were excellent and very tasty. Served with fresh veg and really good friendly Mannar. Also dog friendly
Lovely homely pub. Only had time for a pint but the landlady was very friendly and helpful, the fire was lit and we were made to feel very welcome. The menu looked good and reasonably priced.
Lovely place, lovely food. Service second to none, nothing to much trouble. We will definitely be going back.
Group of 5 plus a dog went on Good Friday all had lovely meals of steak pie, cod, Cajun chicken burger, gammon and lasagna with home made onion rings as a side. All clean plates. Would recommend. Also had a game of darts or too and one of pool upstairs in the games room.
Called in two times over easter weekend great service at bar great atmosphere on Easter Sunday with tunes on jukebox Clare very hospitable found out she grew up with our friends small world will definitely be back 🍻🍻👌
Really great atmosphere, service & food. We was a large party of 11 for Sunday lunch and the staff & food was fantastic. Really made a special family weekend away even better. Thank you.
A lovely pub. Only one veggie option for food. The chips were amazing!
Lovely staff.
One of the best meals I have ever had, if you are up for an affordable meal with high quality food this is the place for you. I really can not fault this pub from the dusty juke box allowing you to choose the music you want to listen to the delicious food. I do recommend dropping this place a visit.
Not much food being served while we were in but the pub was busy with plenty of characters and the ale was reasonably cheap. Tasty beer and a good atmosphere
Spent a few hours in Pickering (was on the NYMR for the day)
Had an excellent lunch and first class beer. Staff very friendly and welcoming. Highly recommend
Always been a good pub with great handpull beers for me and a warm welcome for my dog Isthatgeorgefrommarton. Only had a Sunday lunch from the menu, but very nice. Great range of entertainment and Halloween 🦇 just gone was epic, customers dressed up, Elvis n karaoke, it's what weekend's are for. Roge x n George x
Just visted for some food and what a find had homemade steak & ale pie and scampi with chips and was impressed with the price and the portion sizes were great defo will be returning on our next vist very happy
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes