Reviews The Pudding Pantry - Sherwood

We had a lovely visit here. The food was very tasty and very filling. It was quite expensive but in my opinion it was worth it. The service was great and the staff were very friendly and welcoming and we couldn't fault them. Thank you very much, and we will be back.

What can I say? This area seems to have gentrified and there seems to be a lot of boutique type establishments. The pudding pantry is typical of this area. My wife and I decided to have scrambled eggs on sourdough toast and my daughter had fluffy pancakes with fried chicken. I will say that the whole experience really good and the food was 10 out of 10. Great atmosphere friendly staff very cosy and welcoming. Keep it up.

We were served by the lovely Tamsin who was extremely attentive, kind and friendly :) The food came super quick and tasted amazing! I’d highly recommend this place 10/10

Cannot recommend the Pudding Pantry highly enough. The food is excellent and reasonably priced. There is something for everyone, from brilliant breakfasts to perfect pancakes, with much more. The drinks selection is fantastic and great quality. All this is topped off by the incredible staff. They are always friendly, welcoming and accommodating. Great for kids, families, couples or just stopping in yourself - you won’t be disappointed.

The first time we ever dined in was such a wonderful treat—we had only ever had afternoon tea delivered, so hadn't had food from the main menu. We ordered pancakes for the kids and we had the pulled pork hash and eggs benedict—the pancakes were nearly the size of the plate, even for the kids, and the eggs benedict was next level. The coffee was proper, the service was spot on, and it was just a brilliant brunch. We love to stop by for their massive milkshakes, their second-to-none pumpkin spice latte, coffees, and cakes—it's perfect for a break whilst shopping the high street or a cheeky treat! The second time we went in for brunch, the coffee and service were still amazing, but we left a bit deflated as the food was inconsistent. We ordered pancakes for the kids and the eggs benedict again, but the pancakes were at least half the size that they were the first time on all the dishes. You can see the difference for yourself in the photos—same sized plates, very different sized pancakes. We were so excited to have another amazing brunch, but the stark difference in portion size made it feel like they were out of pancake batter and couldn't be bothered to make more—so it not only felt disappointing, but it felt like we weren't getting the same value for money. The treats and cakes are always exciting and delicious, so it didn't stop us taking some away to enjoy at home—but it did have us wondering if it would be a while before we would take a chance on dining in again anytime soon. We're hoping hoping hoping it was a fluke because we want to love everything about The Pudding Pantry, so I'll update this review once we get around to giving it another go x x

I ordered pantry eggs Benedict via deliveroo from pudding pantry which was yummy. Couple things to mention was the food was quite cold by the time it got to me and one of the pancakes was slightly on the rubbery side on one edge. I’m guessing this is the result of having it delivered. My partner had the homemade beans and cheddar on sourdough and it was warmer but the sourdough was soggy. Flavours were great and can’t wait to go and eat in the shop.

I had tea in some of the most well-known tearooms in London and Oxford in the last week and a half. Then, I chose The Pudding Pantry from a Google Maps search and was absolutely delighted with the food! It is imaginative, the flavors are fresh. Hands down, the best thing I’ve had to eat at any of the places I’ve been was their Raspberry Layer Cake!

My first time visiting The Pudding Pantry today & I was so pleasantly surprised. Our server "Tyler" couldn't of looked after us any better. I'm gluten intolerant and was handed a separate menu listing all the food I could safely order. Our food was gorgeous. I will definitely be visiting again. Thank you to all the staff, especially Tyler 😘

First time of visiting and would definitely recommend and will be returning soon...there are just too many fantastic sounding dishes on the menu! The five of us (2 adults & 3 children) visited for the twins birthday at breakfast/brunch time. Whilst my wife and I kept it real with our selections of smoked salmon & scrambled eggs on sourdough toast and bacon & egg on leek & cabbage potato cakes - both were amazing - our children, however, went with the sweet birthday breakfast...the eldest and his younger brother shared a pancake platter and my daughter enjoyed the cookies and cream freak shake!!! Everything went down really well and I can confirm that the children were not wrong in their praise for their dishes, as I tried it all. 😋